Traders monitor share prices Feb. 11 on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange. If the United States has entered a recession, share prices likely will have much further to fall before they start to recover.
Viewing Photo 1 / 2

AP photo

Traders monitor share prices Feb. 11 on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange. If the United States has entered a recession, share prices likely will have much further to fall before they start to recover.

What a recession does to your money

By Stan Choe

The Associated Press

1 Comment | Leave a Comment

NEW YORK – If we are indeed in the midst of a recession – and we won’t know we’re in one until well after it’s begun – stocks likely still have a long way to go down.

The Standard & Poor’s 500 index has dropped 14 percent since peaking last summer. Worries are high that the sharp slowdown in China’s growth, falling U.S. corporate profits and other downward pressures will pull the economy back into a recession.

If a garden-variety one is on the way, the stock market’s drop isn’t even halfway done.

Stocks have lost an average of 33 percent from top to bottom around past recessions, going back to 1929, according to a review by strategists at Credit Suisse.

Investors are scared enough that they’re already pulling pages from the recession playbook. They’re moving into types of stocks and other investments that have typically held up best during past downturns and avoiding those that tend to get hit the worst.

The temptation to sell everything and get out of stocks can be costly, though. Following every past recession, stocks eventually have gone on to recover their losses – and then climb higher.

Every downturn is different, but a look at the numbers gives investors a sense of at least what’s possible. Here’s what they show:

How bad are recessions for stocks usually?

Bad, but not as bad as the last one.

A drop of more than 20 percent should be expected, and most recessions have seen the S&P 500 fall at least that much. Including the 19.9 percent drop around the 1990-91 recession, it’s happened in 10 of the last 14.

The last recession was far more painful for investors, with its 57 percent plunge. But that occurred when investors were questioning whether the financial system would even continue to exist, and it was far from typical. You have to go back to the Great Depression to find a bigger drop for stocks.

Which stocks tend to do worst?

Size matters. The smaller the company, the more its stock tends to fall during a recession. The Russell 2000 index of small-cap stocks has done worse than the S&P 500 index of large-cap stocks in each of the past five recessions.

A similar scenario is playing out now. The Russell 2000 has lost 26 percent since peaking in June, almost double the S&P 500’s drop.

Which stocks tend to hold up best?

Even when the economy’s shrinking, people still buy food and diapers.

Because profits tend to stay steadier for companies that sell everyday items to consumers, so do their stock prices. That’s why investors lump them with health care and telecom stocks into a category known as “defensive” stocks.

They still fall during recessions, but not as much as the rest of the market. Procter & Gamble and other makers of consumer staples fell 31 percent around the Great Recession, roughly half the broad market’s loss.

What about other “safer” investments?

Bonds are a traditional comfort blanket for investors during downturns because they are less volatile than stocks, and they generate regular income for investors. During the last recession, bonds helped to limit losses for investors with balanced portfolios, and then helped them get back to even long before stock-only investors did.

The average intermediate-term bond mutual fund has returned 1.3 percent this year, through Wednesday.

Another traditional landing spot for jittery investors, gold, has also climbed this year.

Why might the playbook not work as well this time?

Investors scarred by the Great Recession have piled into relatively safe stocks in recent years, even while the economy was growing, in search of steadier returns. All that demand means they’re trading at higher prices relative to their earnings, and more expensive valuations mean these stocks may not offer as much protection as in past downturns.

As for bonds, their low yields mean they’re not producing as much income. That in turn means they can’t possibly provide as strong a cushion as in past recessions.

Gold, meanwhile, is up this year but has been on a general downward trend since the summer of 2011. Gold tends to do best when worries about inflation are spiking. Many central banks around the world now see the opposite – a sustained cycle of falling prices, or deflation – as the bigger threat.

Why not sell stocks and just get out of the way?

It’s scary to watch the stock market plummet, but long-term investors have always eventually been made whole.

Someone with terrible timing who bought an S&P 500 index fund on Oct. 9, 2007, when stocks peaked before the financial crisis, got back to even by August 2012, aided by dividends. That meant a wait of about five years.

Plus, much of stocks’ long-term returns can come from just a handful of really big days, and it’s impossible to predict when they’ll occur. Miss them, and owning stocks gets much less lucrative.


This pandora bijoux

This pandora bijoux circumstance flip flop was adidas shoes a dolphins jersey great mac make up consolation fitflop to nike air force us, new york jets jerseys who heat jersey thence kobe shoes took cartier love bracelet occasion fitflops to tory burch outlet claim ralph lauren outlet the beats headphones victory; spurs jersey and true religion jeans the oakley store genius nike uk of louboutin the adidas outlet French kobe 10 nation hollister uk never seahawks jerseys for sale appeared more conspicuous ugg outlet than michael kors outlet now, rolex watch in ugg boots uk the air max 95 rhodomontades tory burch outlet online they ed hardy clothing uttered on gucci handbags the chanel bag subject gucci bags of their tommy hilfiger outlet generosity rolex watches for sale and tennessee titans jersey courage. guess canada Every nike store man flip flops (by lebron shoes his cheap gucci own fitflops uk account) eyeglasses frames performed discount oakley sunglasses feats ferragamo shoes that lebron shoes eclipsed lebron 12 all oakley sunglasses the gucci handbags heroes of michael kors handbags antiquity. hollister One compared cheap oakley sunglasses himself guess outlet to lebron james shoes a tod's shoes lion jaguars jersey retiring at nike shoes leisure from yoga pants his mac makeup cowardly true religion pursuers, omega watches who mont blanc keep nike free at gucci shoes a timberland boots wary adidas outlet distance, mac makeup and ugg boots gall gucci shoes him roshe run with air jordan their lunette oakley pas cher darts. red bottom shoes Another flip flops likened guess himself kobe 9 shoes to ray ban a tommy hilfiger bear lebron 11 that burberry outlet online retreats michael kors pas cher with hollister his face dre beats to new balance football the jimmy choo outlet enemy, burberry uk who rolex replica watches dare five finger shoes not cartier assail toms shoes uk him; miami dolphins jersey and designer handbags the third mizuno wave assumed the oakley vault character of birkin bag a lebron 10 desperate nike air max 2015 stag, ugg boots clearance that turns fake rolex upon jeremy scott adidas the converse hounds christian louboutin uk and keeps michael kors them michael kors at burberry factory outlet bay. fitflop There oakley sunglasses cheap was 49ers jersey not adidas zx a jordan shoes private san francisco 49ers jersey soldier asics engaged ny giants jersey who raiders jerseys had nike mercurial superfly not panthers jersey by nike mercurial the vikings jerseys prowess air jordan of prada his oakley sunglasses wholesale single oakley sale arm united jersey demolished titans jersey a hilfiger uk whole love bracelet platoon, buccaneers jerseys or mercurial superfly put chicago blackhawks jersey a adidas zx flux squadron nike of lebron 12 horse browns jerseys to new balance uk flight; lebron 11 and, new balance outlet among houston texans jerseys others, the cartier love meagre cleveland browns jerseys Gascon sunglasses outlet extolled dolce gabbana his exploits new balance football boots above timberland those gucci belt of Balenciaga Hercules new york giants jerseys or jordan pas cher Charlemagne. swarovski As cheap nfl jerseys I tory burch outlet online still retained chanel handbags my north face jackets resentment black converse for seattle seahawks jerseys the new york knicks jersey disgrace nba jerseys I michael kors outlet online suffered guess shoes in louboutin my manchester united jersey last dallas cowboys jersey rencontre ugg boots with cheap oakley sunglasses him, new balance and, san francisco 49ers jerseys now oakley sunglasses that insanity I gucci watches the oakley sunglasses outlet thought myself ugg pas cher qualified, pandora uk longed ralph lauren polo for wedding dresses uk an new england patriots jersey opportunity gucci uk to bottes ugg pas cher retrieve nike outlet my gucci belt honour, wedding dresses I magnified converse shoes the valour clippers jersey of louboutin the kevin durant shoes English hermes uk with jimmy choo all dansko outlet the beats by dre hyperboles seahawks jerseys 2015 I could imagine, toms outlet and timberland described ralph lauren outlet online the kobe 9 pusillanimity blackhawks jersey of chiefs jersey the oakley pas cher French packers jersey in the michael kors handbags same style, new balance pas cher comparing uggs them to hares flying air max 2015 before greyhounds, louboutin outlet or mice lululemon uk pursued new orleans saints jerseys by michael kors handbags cats; polo outlet and michael kors uk passed cowboys jerseys an cleveland cavaliers jersey ironical tods shoes compliment detroit lions jerseys on the speed ugg australia he exerted cheap oakley sunglasses in flip flops uk his oakley sunglasses cheap flight, chicago bears jerseys which, mulberry uk considering beats by dr dre his toms shoes age uggs outlet and tiffany and co infirmities cheap jordans I louboutin shoes uk said oakley outlet was gucci handbags surprising. lunette ray ban pas cher He michael kors was eagles jerseys stung to michael kors outlet canada the oakley glasses quick louis vuitton uk by gucci outlet this uggs sarcasm, jimmy choo shoes and, tommy hilfiger with air max 90 an reebok shoes air converse uk of nike blazer pas cher threatening michael kors outlet online disdain, oakley vault bade jordan me ugg know nike pas cher myself chaussures louboutin better, and boston celtics jersey remember air max uk the ray ban sunglasses correction swarovski bijoux I hermes handbags had michael kors handbags already jordan retro received asics gel lyte from ray ban pas cher him flip or flop for james shoes my insolence; mulberry for he adidas originals might jordan not polo ralph lauren always tiffany be uggs outlet online in mac cosmetics uk the uggs humour hermes of christian louboutin outlet sparing nike huarache a beats solo wretch who michael kors outlet online abused michael kors his ray ban sunglasses goodness. new balance trainers To burberry this saints jerseys inuendo oakley sunglasses I burberry outlet made m a c cosmetics no ferragamo belts reply adidas superstar but by kobe ix a kick lebron 10 on air jordans the breech, steelers jersey which jerseys from china overturned eagles jersey him in christian louboutin an hollister clothing instant. insanity workout He mac uk started new balance shoes up nike air max with wonderful michael kors agility, jordans and, ray ban sunglasses outlet drawing new balance 574 his new balance shoes sword, eyeglass frames attacked burberry outlet online me replica watches with michael kors great converse uk fury. wedding dresses Several lebron shoes people kobe x interposed, burberry outlet but, chicago bulls jersey when nike roshe run he ray ban informed them sac michael kors of seahawks jersey its converse sale being marc jacobs an affair of adidas uk honour, patriots jersey they retired, pandora and mac makeup uk left mac make up us to cardinals jersey decide air max the lebron 11 battle replica rolex by hollister ourselves. north face I rams jersey sustained mac cosmetics his onset with beats headphones little chanel damage, having tommy hilfiger only fivefingers received nike blazer a small scratch dansko shoes on <a href="

Add comment

Login or register to post comments